|
All
About Eve
(1950)
Cast:Bette Davis (Margo Channing), Anne Baxter (Eve
Harrington), George Sanders (Addison DeWitt), Celeste
Holm (Karen Richards), Gary Merrill (Bill Sampson),
Hugh Marlowe (Lloyd Richards), Gregory Ratoff (Max Fabian),
Barbara Bates (Phoebe), Marilyn Monroe (Claudia Casswell),
Thelma Ritter (Birdie Coonan)
Crew:Direction
Joseph L. Mankiewicz, Writing Joseph L. Mankiewicz,
Producing Darryl F. Zanuck, Music Alfred Newman, Cinematography
Milton R. Krasner, Editing Barbara McLean, Art Direction
George W. Davis and Lyle R. Wheeler, Set Direction Thomas
Little and Walter M. Scott, Costume Design Edith Head
and Charles Le Maire, Production Company 20th Century
Fox, Distributor 20th Century Fox Length: 138 minutes
|
|
Academy
Awards:
Won for Best Picture (Darryl F. Zanuck) · Won for Best
Director (Joseph L. Mankiewicz) · Won for Best Writing,
Screenplay (Joseph L. Mankiewicz) · Won for Best Actor
in a Supporting Role (George Sanders) · Won for Best
Costume Design, Black-and-White (Edith Head and Charles
Le Maire) · Won for Best Sound, Recording · Nominated
for Best Actress in a Leading Role (Anne Baxter) · Nominated
for Best Actress in a Leading Role (Bette Davis) · Nominated
for Best Actress in a Supporting Role (Celeste Holm)
· Nominated for Best Actress in a Supporting Role (Thelma
Ritter) · Nominated for Best Art Direction-Set Decoration,
Black-and-White (George W. Davis, Thomas Little, Walter
M. Scott and Lyle R. Wheeler) · Nominated for Best Cinematography,
Black-and-White (Milton R. Krasner) · Nominated for
Best Film Editing (Barbara McLean) · Nominated for Best
Music, Scoring of a Dramatic or Comedy Picture (Alfred
Newman)
Golden Globes:
Won for Best Screenplay (Joseph L. Mankiewicz)
National
Film Preservation Board: 1990 Entry into the National
Film Registry
|
|
There are few pleasures in movie going greater than listening
to the script for All About Eve as written by Joseph Mankiewicz
taking inspiration from the story "The Wisdom of Eve" by Mary
Orr and then performed by the movie's cast headlined by Bette
Davis acting in the central role of Margo Channing. At once
arresting with its cynical observations run-through with startlingly
insightful thoughts on the make believe world of the theater,
the film is a genuine pleasure no matter how much time passes
from when it was first released in theaters.
As one of the legendary productions of Hollywood's golden
age, and certainly one of the jewels in the crown of one of
that age's most renowned studios, 20th Century Fox, All About
Eve is art projected at 24 frames a second. In just over two
hours running time a tale of opportunism, entertainment, deceit
and the struggles of growing older are put on display with
truly terrific narrative devices rarely used for greater impact
than within Mankiewicz's film.
Opening with an awards ceremony celebrating the actress Eve
Harrington (Ann Baxter), Addison DeWitt (George Sanders),
noted theatrical critic and soulless hanger-on to the world
of artifice and performance, informs us through his first
voice-over that Eve's rise to prominence was anything but
the triumph of talent over circumstance. Instead Eve's journey
from anonymity to superstardom is the stuff of legend insofar
as it exposes the unnatural competition, petty opportunism
and overall emptiness of the entertainment industry. DeWitt's
remarks and indifferent feelings punctuate this point and
bring about an understanding of fame's cost but also the way
it's achieved that is anything but idealistic and pure.
His
revelations of Eve, as told through freeze frames, frequent
voice-over narrations and a wraparound structure containing
the central story told in flashback, is that she's everything
fame requires but nothing the myth of celebrity suggests.
She's not particularly sweet, good tempered, kind or humble.
Nor is she untalented, lazy, misguided or dim. Always ambitious,
fortunately young and easily allied with circumstance to benefit
her goals of wealth and celebrity, Eve is a climber without
restraint or conscience.
She
is nothing more and nothing less than a manipulative sycophant
who attached herself to the star of Margo Channing, her most
obvious role model for having already achieved the kind of
success Eve herself clamors for from the word go. By absorbing
Margo's tendencies and by capitalizing on her contacts Eve
gradually becomes first her confidante and friend and, eventually,
her competitor, successor and enemy. In this journey she's
aided at certain critical junctures by Addison's unusual influence
and sense of timing, though never without paying her pound
of flesh since Addison is self-serving from a seemingly endless
supply of stories and lesser personalities to grind through
his mill of gossip and intrigue.
Of course there are other parties involved in this shifting
battle for career success and professional dominance as waged
between Eve and her defensive nemesis Margo. There is Margo's
boyfriend, the theater and film director Bill Sampson (Gary
Merrill), Margo's longtime friend Karen Richards (Celeste
Holm) and her husband, the playwright Lloyd Richards (Hugh
Marlowe), who, together, introduce Eve to Margo in the first
place. Then there are several characters who fill out the
seams between mentor and usurper including the theater and
movie producer Max Fabian (Gregory Ratoff), starlet Claudia
Casswell (Marilyn Monroe) and Margo's right-hand Birdie Coonan
(Thelma Ritter), herself a retired vaudevillian with a reflex
approach to judging human nature.
Concluding the film's action and linear storyline by returning
to the awards show bookend first introduced at the beginning
of the film, Eve receives her comeuppance at the hands of
Addison who alone knows the truth of her newly crowned star.
In short order, he is the one who knows, "all about Eve",
and it's his revelation that fully demonstrates the cynical
quality of show business as Eve falls victim to her very own
minion in the form of another sycophantic wannabe named Phoebe
(Barbara Bates) in the film's end.
Summarizing All About Eve in this way, though, fails to offer
complete remarks concerning its genius. Without ignoring the
contributions of the film's composer Alfred Newman, its cinematographer
Milton R. Krasner, editor Barbara McLean and the production
design team of George W. Davis, Thomas Little, Walter M. Scott
and Lyle R. Wheeler, it's easy to gloss over the writing and
narrative structure to instead focus on performance.
The most famous relationship of the film is the pairing of
Anne Baxter and Bette Davis in the central roles but there
is more to enjoy than the struggle between an aging star and
her limelight-addicted upstart. Layers of relationships dot
the film with a commanding vocabulary of interrelated lives
including Eve's reluctant alliance with Addison to the difficulties
of a static marriage between Karen and Lloyd. There is also
the simultaneous expression of love and exasperation by Margo
and Bill that repeatedly considers the levels of trust, distrust,
ease and disease shared by people whose lives are always in
a state of negotiation and change.
Never
without choice words, comic timing and the teeth of tragedy
each of these combinations spin around one another to expose
the constructed nature of make believe. The theatrical tradition
is specifically skewered but so is the motion picture industry
with a number of "in" jokes, some of which refer to the film's
producer Darryl Zanuck while still others refer place names
in Hollywood and the ritual bicoastal lives of stage actors
clamoring for the greater commercial rewards of Los Angeles.
Reportedly Zanuck originally envisioned Marlene Dietrich in
the part of Margo Channing with Jeanne Crain as Eve Harrington
and José Ferrer as Addison DeWitt. Mankiewicz's early choices
for the same part included Claudette Colbert and Gertrude
Lawrence although the cinematic record clearly shows that
Davis won the part and made it one of the all-time great showpieces
for any actress working in American movies.
The
net effect of this background the resulting expression of
All About Eve is the fact of its being a treasure of world
cinema. Arguments against it would necessarily be restricted
to short-sighted considerations about the aesthetic criteria
associated with black and white movies, the requirement of
watching the film with considerable attention so as not to
miss the use of language and perhaps even undue emphasis on
the occasionally ineffective rear projection outdoor scenes.
Ignoring these points, however, yields a movie experience
very close to being an epiphany.
Unlike certain years when the Academy Awards race is decided
between a series of acceptable though unexceptional titles,
1950 was a remarkable time. The Academy of Motion Picture
Arts and Sciences saw fit to give All About Eve the Best Motion
Picture award but it very easily could have gone to one of
a couple of other titles as well. Billy Wilder released Sunset
Boulevard and received a movie of the year nomination alongside
the productions of Born Yesterday and Father of the Bride.
King Solomon's Mines was also nominated for Best Motion Picture
and though it was far outclassed by its more literary competitors
it was still a valid entry in the year-end awards derby.
History also reveals that the Academy avoided giving Oscar
nominations to at least three other titles that have since
been considered exceptional works. Rules of the Game, The
Third Man and Adam's Rib were all released to varied popular
interest and acclaim in 1950. Of the three Rules of the Game
has been lifted into the pantheon of great American movies
while The Third Man and Adam's Rib have been assigned likable
places among the genre classics of Hollywood's golden period
in the immediate post-War moment.
I mention these points of context to emphasize the strength
of certain pictures released in competition for box office
dollars and critical adulation in 1950 but also to point out
that All About Eve was considered the very best of its vintage.
More to the point, subsequent years have only sweetened the
regard for Mankiewicz's film that won six Oscars from among
14 nominations while containing some of the greatest dialogue
ever written for sound movies.
Years
later, and with the melancholic nod of certain filmmakers
who sometimes homage masters of the form in their more contemporary
back stage dramas and inside-show business exposes, they are
almost always forced to run through the plot points and characters
developed in All About Eve. Thus the film has also achieved
a certain kind of immortality. It focuses on an aging star's
hysteria with losing her looks and her place within a career
that depends on surfaces, youth and disposable performers.
But it also takes the perspective of inveterate insider Addison
DeWitt who always survives ever-changing circumstances to
see Margo eclipsed by Eve and then enjoy the anticipation
of seeing Eve's stardom eroded by Phoebe, if not the next
wannabe starlet or the next.
Such
cynicism is often used to give depth and weight to stereotypical
characters and enliven otherwise conventional circumstances.
This is because it's an easily understood trope for creating
good and evil polarities while telling a story. But cynicism
is rarely the overall tone of a film, nor its purpose.
Mankiewicz uses cynicism in the person and character of Addison
who is the film's narrative fulcrum although he is not meant
to negate the magic of show business or the very real pursuits
of fortune and fame that plague artists like Margo, Eve, Bill
and Lloyd. Instead Mankiewicz infuses the film with its cynical
theme as a method for criticizing the false sentiments that
under gird our entertainment industry. Fortunately this same
facility, experience and expertise used to criticize show
business is itself a kind of brilliance for which we bow our
heads.
As a summary statement concerning All About Eve it should
be remembered for being a behind the scenes look at stardom
and the live theater. That we can also interpret it as an
expose of the relationships, cross-purposes and ambitions
that create entertainment, not to mention the very magical
dialogue employed to this end, means it's something more than
a good movie. In fact, it's one of the singular films every
given the Academy Award for picture of the year and it is
this final point that has cemented its place in history.
|