|
Coming
Home
(1978)
Cast:Jane Fonda (Sally Hyde), Jon Voight (Luke Martin),
Bruce Dern (Captain Bob Hyde), Penelope Milford (Viola
"Vi" Munson), Robert Carradine (Bill Munson), Robert
Ginty (Sergeant Dink Mobley), Mary Gregory (Martha Vickery),
Kathleen Miller (Kathy Delise), Beeson Carroll (Captain
Carl Delise), Willie Tyler (Virgil Hunt)
Crew:Direction
Hal Ashby, Writing Nancy Dowd (story), Robert C. Jones,
Waldo Salt and Rudy Wurlitzer, Producing Jerome Hellman,
Cinematography Haskell Wexler, Editing Don Zimmerman,
Production Design Michael D. Haller, Costume Design
Ann Roth, Production Company Jayne Productions and Jerome
Hellman Productions, Distributor United Artists Length:
126 minutes
|
|
Academy
Awards:
Won for Best Writing, Screenplay Written Directly for
the Screen (Nancy Dowd, Robert C. Jones and Waldo Salt)
· Won for Best Actor in a Leading Role (Jon Voight)
· Won for Best Actress in a Leading Role (Jane Fonda)
· Nominated for Best Picture (Jerome Hellman) · Nominated
for Best Director (Hal Ashby) · Nominated for Best Actor
in a Supporting Role (Bruce Dern) · Nominated for Best
Actress in a Supporting Role (Penelope Milford) · Nominated
for Best Film Editing (Don Zimmerman)
Golden Globes:
Won for Best Motion Picture Actor - Drama (Jon Voight)
· Won for Best Motion Picture Actress - Drama (Jane
Fonda) · Nominated for Best Motion Picture - Drama ·
Nominated for Best Director - Motion Picture (Hal Ashby)
· Nominated for Best Screenplay - Motion Picture (Robert
C. Jones and Waldo Salt) · Nominated for Best Motion
Picture Actor in a Supporting Role (Bruce Dern)
|
|
There's something brittle, delicate and simultaneously course
about the off-putting refinement of Jane Fonda. Long brown
hair, her father's features, an athlete's body and crisp speech
pattern make her a marm and a prude. In certain circumstances
she can also be pinched or castrating, perhaps even cruel,
but the layers of her personality are somewhat more complex
and tender than what's given common view in tokens like "Hanoi
Jane" or Barbarella.
Likewise
John Voight is boyishly handsome with barely suppressed sexual
magnetism. Roundish cheeks, blonde hair, a winning smile and
open personality mark him as someone to know and approach.
He seems like a nice guy absent any malice of intention and
it's this quality of forgiveness attached to his never questionable
masculinity that makes him attractive and charismatic.
Imagine,
then, their alchemical combination in Coming Home, the Hal
Ashby-directed drama combining parallel parts of their respective
personas and reversing them for heart-rending effect. She's
Sally Hyde, the repressed and confused wife of Captain Bob
Hyde (Bruce Dern), a Vietnam era marine awaiting his chance
to kill commies in country. He's Luke Martin, the high school
phantom of Sally's youth turned veteran paraplegic who struggles
with his mental and physical health in a stateside VA hospital.
Scored with some of the greatest hits of Motown and late '60s
rock, this Academy Award-nominated film is a touching portrait
of war and consequence. Its strength is believable writing,
strong performances and a microcosm of the Vietnam era played
through an insulated group of people brought together by chance
circumstances.
Unlike other films of its moment, especially 1978's Oscar
winner in Michael Cimino's The Deer Hunter or Francis Ford
Coppola's 1979 masterwork Apocalypse Now, Coming Home isn't
focused on the field of battle. Instead it's centered on the
aftermath of war and the transformations required of those
done with their fighting alongside those bearing witness to
the wounds of body and spirit. It breathes life into the legions
of non-hero heroes and the nearly unendurable process of integrating
figurative shrapnel from wartime ordinance into the relative
safety of home.
Opening
just before Bob is sent to the hot zone, the Hydes are a couple
on the brink of collapse. He's a warmonger itching to test
his masculinity and she's frightened of losing him to the
clip of a VC bullet. Together they fulfill an old-fashioned
model of family with him in the work force and her keeping
the home fires warm for his safe return.
When Bob leaves for his tour Sally strikes up a friendship
with Viola "Vi" Munson (Penelope Milford), the girlfriend
of her husband's friend, Sergeant Dink Mobley (Robert Ginty).
With time on her hands and unpleasant worries in her mind
as a military wife, Sally volunteers at the VA hospital where
Vi is a nutritionist and begins her metamorphosis from a wallflower
into a self-determined modern woman.
In the midst of sorting bedpans, pouring coffee and primping
pillows, she bumps into Luke who was someone she admired in
high school. Now, some years later, he's convalescing, trying
to learn how to manage his paralyzing spinal cord injury sustained
while leading his platoon into battle. He's feisty, disagreeable
and deeply troubled by the senselessness of his experience
in Southeast Asia. Yet he's also needy and sensitive to circumstance,
enough so that he recognizes a kindred neediness in Sally
who's waiting for news of her husband.
Eventually
they strike up a friendship, though Luke doubts her sincerity
as nothing more than a way to prepare for Bob's return, possibly
in a body bag. With passing days and weeks their friendship
becomes a mutual struggle for self-transformation. Luke learns
to accept his injury through Sally's no-nonsense support while
she learns to fulfill herself under the glow of his attention
and encouragement. They fall in love, eventually make love
and share passions not strictly based on body affection.
Like a lost man at sea, though, Bob hosts his wife for a brief
visit in Asia and displays the fissures of unfulfilled ambition
that are his lot in life. Unable to assimilate the horrors
of battle with the requirements of his marriage, he's a failure
as a husband and warrior.
Sally intuitively know her life with Bob is forever changed,
but that she's committed to him and to his safe return when
his tour is ended. Returning stateside she gets a perm, buys
a new car, leaps headlong into her career of volunteerism
and becomes the sort of active person her husband never wanted
or craved.
Luke finally leaves the hospital but returns to helplessly
witness the suicide of Vi's younger brother, Bill Munson (Robert
Carradine), another troubled veteran who found life in America
too difficult to bear. Reacting to Bill's tragic passing Luke
chains himself to the gates of a marine recruitment center
thereby awakening a political interest and inviting the ire
of the federal government. His nascent pacifism slowly awakens
to post-war possibilities where he can fight his battles with
words and not bullets or bayonets.
When
Bob unexpectedly returns home a hero, but one with an accidentally
self-inflicted wound, the conflicts of Sally's two loves becomes
clear. All the more so when Bob is shown pictures of Sally
of Luke together since Luke has been surveilled by the government
as a provocateur and threat to national security following
his attempt to close down the recruitment center.
Confronting his wife after several drunken binges and hysterical
outbursts, Bob breaks with reality and approaches Sally with
a gun. Screaming about the war and her betrayal, his own impotence
and lack of control, Luke intervenes to try and catalyze Bob's
recovery before moving out of their life altogether. As Sally
and Vi go shopping for groceries in their tentative return
to normalcy, Bob strips naked and swims to his doom in the
great, wide, Pacific Ocean while Luke speaks to a group of
high school students about the reality of war and the conflicting
calls of patriotism.
Tagged
with the flip line, "A man who believed in war! A man who
believed in nothing! And a woman who believed in both of them!"
Coming Home is something more than a romance and something
less than a war movie. Not beholden to the normal cues of
a sweeping symphonic score, exotic locales and often whispered
"I love yous", it's defined by its Vietnam context that's
used as a structuring fable about love and forgiveness, change
and stasis, war and peace. There is no happy ending, no final
standoff against bad guys storming the trenches and with this
connection of disparate genres Ashby's film succeeds magnificently.
Over
the years Coming Home has also managed to be that brand of
historical artifact that speaks to its moment as well as to
future generations. It's indeed caught within the cycle of
mid- to late-'70s political reactions to earlier times but
its lessons, emotions and artistic integrity are timeless
and impressive regardless of comparison with other films about
the American War in Vietnam. Owing to the script by Nancy
Dowd, Robert C. Jones and Waldo Salt, the characters are able
to voice ideological impressions of war but they're always,
first and foremost, people struggling to find a way to survive
the peace.
Perhaps in comparison to other Vietnam movies Coming Home
shines all the more with its disruption of traditional notions
about star power and war films. By rendering Fonda an adulteress
without a personality and Voight a urine-bag carrying paraplegic,
these two actors made creative leaps that were outright persona
reversals. Not just because the roles ignored much of their
hard won star value but also because the parts forced them
to occupy screen time as Sally and Luke, two symbols of a
wider America experience of Vietnam.
Thus Sally and Luke are ideas as well as characters. They
are halves of a bruised soul finding solace in the acceptance
and discovery of tenderness and affection. Moreover they are
aspects of war told through the daily struggles of people
not present in the theater of battle but who, through association
and sacrifice, are forced to handle themselves with humility
and forgiveness as victims of the war just the same.
Of
course there is a moral hole at the center of the film. Sally
does cheat on her husband. And though Bob is almost a hawkish
cipher for masculine posturing run amuck, it doesn't excuse
her infidelity to say he's a troll without enough regard for
her needs or experience.
That Luke is so appealing is a factor of his disability and
of Voight's skill as an actor. Sexual pity too plays a role
in his charismatic performance that can't help but be read
into Sally's affection for a wheelchair-bound hero. Still,
it's enough to admit that Luke's neutral qualities and loneliness
are somehow universal, worthy of rewarding his better qualities
with love and the joys of companionship, especially since
he ends up a fundamentally moral person.
In the final analysis, Coming Home is a minor masterpiece.
Long celebrated for its writing and lead performances, it's
also unfettered by its liberal guilt in criticizing war, any
war, as an unnecessary evil stemming from misplaced national
self-interest. Though this commentary is everywhere present
in the film, the honesty and complexity of Sally and Luke's
struggle redeem any propagandistic element in the production.
Aside from presenting a left-leaning soapbox the film offers
a vision of war without napalm, nighttime raids or the terrors
of hellishly heroic bloodshed. Simply put, Coming Home presents
a war of emotions, scars and memories as potent as any bandoliers,
air cavalry raids or bouncing Betties ever could be.
|